Printing 

Tips and Techniques
from Jeff Adams
revision 11-20-2007


Jeff's Digital Imaging Information
Home

Software
Basics

Differences between Elements and CS
Differences

CS info
Making the transition from Elements to CS

Photoshop Elements and CS Tutorials
Tutorials

RAW
RAW file management

Photoshop Extras
Plugins, Filters, Actions, Templates, Brushes, Fonts, Papers, and more!

Getting Correct Color (Color Management)
Color Management

Printing Tips and Help
Printing

Epson ICC profile information
http://www.epson.com/cgi-bin/Store/EditorialAnnouncement.jsp?oid=42114986
ftp://ftp.epson.com/webfiles/icc/Color-Managed-Workflow.pdf




Seriously: 
Have you read the excellent User's Guides and Help information that came with either Elements or Photoshop in the help files?  If not, please start there.  Reading web sites is a good idea - that's why I built this site, but if you skipped the User's Guides that came with your software you're driving your car without a license.


New to Inkjet Printing?  Here are Your First Assignments...

Have you read the excellent User's Guides and Help information that came with either Elements or Photoshop in the help files?  If not, please start there.  Reading web sites is a good idea - that's why I built this site, but if you skipped the User's Guides that came with your software you're driving your car without a license. I have pasted some of their help files below.

Have you read thru the steps in my Color web page?
Color Management


Here are the Elements User's Guides
Elements 3   69 page User Guide
Elements 4   471 page User Guide
Elements 5  User Guide
Elements 6  User Guide


Ask Jeff for copies of good articles. 

View some of the Epson online course episodes featuring color management explanations - they are very good.  Ask Jeff


View some of Vincent Bockaert's 123DI interactive CD segments on color - they are great.  Ask Jeff.

View some of the Total Training DVD's in the Ed. Tech. Center - ask Jeff.

View the Luminous Landscape DVD on setting up your workflow and color.  Ask Jeff

Is your camera set to Adobe RGB (1998)?


Do you know how to set up color management in your editing software?

Will you calibrate your monitor using Adobe Gamma or Colorvision Spyder2/Monaco

Buying a new monitor?  Start here

What printer are you going to use on a regular basis...(stick with that for your test and control purposes)?

If you are farming out your printing how are you communicating color space choices and test runs with your commercial printer?

Know your experts:  Dan Margulis (NAPP), Pat Russotti - RIT, Mike Dear - RIT, John Paul Caponigro, Tim Grey, Deke McClelland, Dave Cross (NAPP), Scott Kelby (NAPP), Katrin Eismann, Greg Gorman, Mac Holbert, Vincent Versace, Galer and Andrews, Rob Sheppard, Andrew Rodney, Harald Johnson, Michael Reichmann, Bill Atkinson, Don Niemann, Martin Evening, Ian Lyons at Computer-Darkroom

Understand good workflow techniques with Radiant Vista



Basics

Epson ICC profile information
http://www.epson.com/cgi-bin/Store/EditorialAnnouncement.jsp?oid=42114986
ftp://ftp.epson.com/webfiles/icc/Color-Managed-Workflow.pdf


Russell Brown online video on printing from Photoshop to an Epson 2200 - very good (takes a moment for the audio to start)
http://av.adobe.com/russellbrown/PhotoshopCSPrinSM.mov


Have you read the excellent User's Guides and Help information that came with either Elements or Photoshop in the help files?  If not, please start there.  Reading web sites is a good idea - that's why I built this site, but if you skipped the User's Guides that came with your software you're driving your car without a license.

Start here - Adobe inkjet printer and color basics
and a 16 page pdf from Adobe on color management that is very good

Windows (official Windows site) color management - start here
Color Management and Windows - Tim Grey

Start here - Dry Creek Photo basic info

This is very good from Colorvision on all the basics you need to know (from www.calibratenow.net)

Apple users - you might like these web sites (thanks to Jack Graham)
for printing with Epson printers from Photoshop CS2 PS9 under Apple Mac OSX TIGER 10.4 and PANTHER 10
http://www.gballard.net/psd/epson_cs2.html

Main Complete Workflow Tutorial gballard.net
http://www.gballard.net/nca.html


Steve's Digicam's web site has great info Help My Printer Profiles Aren't Working!
Lighting, Viewing, and Metamerism
Softproofing Basics
Understanding Rendering Intents
Color Management in a Nutshell
PPI, DPI, and resolution
Color Management with Epson Printers
Color Manangement with Canon Printers

And don't skip this one - Ian Lyons Computer-Darkroom basic color management
(includes good info on softproofing)

Tim Grey basic article on Color Management

Adobe basics

Outback Photo basics

Olympus Corp basic diagrams and workflow - very visual

Vincent's guide to color management

Local labs that know how to deal with color issues

Good basic overview from informit.com

Order free materials from Xrite (Monaco)

Good basic info from MS
http://www.microsoft.com/whdc/device/display/color/default.mspx

Good info
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Color_management

Martin Evening's color mgmt pdf - based on ps7 but good
http://www.earthboundlight.com/phototips/color-management-feeling-lost.html

Very basic but clear!
http://www.outdooreyes.com/photo91.php3

Radiant Vista
podcasts on color management

Luminous Landscape tutorial on printers and color

Photoshop TV


Step by Step Tips:

Here are the steps I recommend for proceeding through color management from camera to printer:

Step
Task
Links
1

CAMERA
If you plan to edit and print your own photos change your camera color space setting to Adobe RGB.  It probably is on sRGB if you have never changed it.
If you are happy with your camera's images then leave the setting on sRGB.

Read your camera manual to see how the manufacturer tells you to deal with color spaces.

Canon 10D, 20D, Rebel and XT users will want to read specific info in your user's guides about this option:  page 62 in the Rebel XT350 manual; page 58 in the 10D manual; page 56 in the 20D manual.

Mike Chaney's great article on in camera color spaces from Oct 2006

Another very good starter article from Mike Chaney
2

CAMERA
Make sure you have left the saturation, contrast, and sharpness settings in the default mode on your camera.  Don't boost or cut anything in your camera, let the software do this step.


2 a

CAMERA
If you want black and white prints - shoot in color and adjust the color image later on to obtain the best black and white.

3



MONITOR
Use some type of monitor calibration tool.  Use Adobe Gamma, which is located in the Windows control panel area to adjust contrast, brightness, and colors if you have Adobe software.  This utility self installs in your control panel when you install Adobe software, it's free, just use it.  If you can afford a third party colorimeter, then use that device to measure and correct your monitor instead of Adobe Gamma.

Note:  If your monitor is not accurate then you are making inaccurate decisions in your editing software regarding contrast (tonal information), color saturation, and hue changes.  And, don't try to compensate for this inaccuracy by skewing your printer color controls.

Colorimeters (Colorvision, Pantone, Monaco, etc.)
4


MONITOR
If you are using a laptop PC or Mac, or an LCD monitor on your desktop pc, then ask me for help in setting up color.  Do you know how to adjust your laptop pc's brightness and contrast?  My experiences so far have been marginal in trying to make an LCD monitor look as good as my better flat screen LaCie or Sony CRT's.  Just my opinion....

Setting up your monitor correctly
5



SOFTWARE
Read your software help information to see how the manufacturer suggests you deal with setting up color preferences.  Photoshop, Elements, Paint Shop Pro, Microsoft, etc. all will tell you something a little different.

My experiences so far tell me that Adobe is all over the place when it comes to saying and doing color management between their different pieces of software.  Photoshop CS2 has the clearest info to date.


6

SOFTWARE
Get a reliable test image and make a test print to see how close you are to a good print.  Don't fix things until you know what you are fixing.  Test Images.

When you first open an image file try doing a Save As command and look around in that dialog box for information as to what color space you are about to tag your image with.    Many times this will be a surprise and you'll find that even though you thought you were tagging your file with Adobe RGB - if you intend to print the image -  it's not showing up that way in the dialog box.

In most software the next step is to go to the Color Settings preferences dialog boxes and reset your options to the color space you want.  sRGB for screen and web output; Adobe RGB for printer output.

Photoshop Elements Color Help

Photoshop CS2 Color Help

7


SOFTWARE
When you edit your image, if you are using Photoshop CS2, then start checking your output quality before you print by using the View > Soft Proof options.  If you are not familiar with Soft Proofing then go to Photoshop's help command and do some reading on this.  This option let's you see how your image will look based on your printer, your paper you plan to use, and your existing adjustment layers.  Consider flattening your image then adding one more adjustment layer while soft proofing to see if you need to boost or cut saturation or tonal levels.

Note:  Soft Proofing is not available in Elements.

Ian Lyons Computer-Darkroom basic color management
(includes good info on soft proofing)

Softproofing basics from Steve's

Profile mismatches, etc were covered really well in PSTV Episode #59 - December 2006


8


PRINTER
Download and install paper .icc paper profiles for the type and brand of paper you will be using.  I know this may put many of you to sleep, but stick with this step.

Here is information for Kodak papers just as an example.  I use only Epson papers, but let's not get too hooked on Epson if Kodak papers will provide the quality you need.
Kodak professional inkjet papers separate pdf's for PS and El.

Note:  The following is excerpted from Kodak's web page: 

What is a color profile?

A color printer profile is a small software file that describes how ink interacts with a specific type of paper, within a specific printing system. In this case, your printer. Using the right ICC Color Profile for your printer is one of the easiest steps you can take toward better prints. Your print driver will use the profile to adjust the output of ink to match the colors, contrast, and brightness in the picture file. The result is better, more consistent, even amazing prints.

Your printer came with profiles that are specific to the manufacturer’s paper, but all papers are made slightly (or dramatically) different. By using the profiles we made specifically for your printer (along with the correct Printer Driver settings), you’ll get the best possible prints on KODAK PROFESSIONAL Inkjet Photo Paper. If you’re looking for color predictability and consistency, download the profile for your printer and operating system, and get the results you expect – every time.

Luminous Landscape tutorial on printers and color

Epson color workflow for Epson printers

Steve's digicams printer profile help


9

PRINTER
Learn how to let your software determine the colors your printer will use to make the print, not your printer color controls.  Sounds weird right?  The idea here is to literally turn off the color controls in your printer and let your software manage this process.  You are still going to select the paper type, paper size, dots per inch of ink spray (usually 1440 dpi or 2880 dpi with Epson's), speed of printing, edge smoothing, etc. in the printer dialog box, but you are going to turn off the printer's color controls.

Adobe inkjet printer and color basics






Books

Print Like a Pro by Jon Canfield

Mastering Digital Printing, 2nd edition,  Harald Johnson, 2003.

Epson Printing Handbook, revised, Rob Sheppard





Discussion Forums


Dave Etchell's Imaging Resource Forums  http://www.photo-forums.com/WebX?14@@.ee6b2a8
Phil Askey's DP Review Forums http://www.dpreview.com/forums/
Steve Sander's Steve's Digicams Forums http://www.stevesforums.com/forums/
Jeff Keller's DC Resource Forums http://www.dcresource.com/forums/
Fred Miranda's Forums http://www.fredmiranda.com/forum/
M. Reichmann's Luminous Landscape Forums http://www.luminous-landscape.com/cgi-bin/forum/ikonboard.cgi
Photography Review's Forums http://forums.photographyreview.com/
Rob Galbraith's Forums http://forums.robgalbraith.com/ubbthreads.php
Digital Outback Photo's Forums http://www.outbackphoto.com/tforum/
Adobe http://www.adobe.com/support/forums/main.html
Layers Magazine forums http://www.layersmagazine.com/forum/
Adobe Photoshop Elements forum from ElementsUser http://www.photoshopelementsuser.com/forum/

http://dpnow.com/Forums.html
http://www.popphoto.com/idealbb/
Google Groups
Msn's Groups http://groups.msn.com/browse.msnw?catid=124





Test Images

Test images - there are 4 total, just change the number from test1 to test2, etc.
http://paws.flcc.edu/~adamsja/digital/classtestimages/test1.jpg

Good Tim Grey targets for determining if you are able to print anything in the lower and upper 10 steps out of 256
http://www.timgrey.com/PrintTarget.jpg
http://www.timgrey.com/ccdownloads.htm

Good pdf and test images
http://creative.gettyimages.com/source/services/colorResources.aspx

Norman's site and direct links to test images
http://www.normankoren.com/makingfineprints1A.html#QuickGamma

Caponigro's test files
http://www.johnpaulcaponigro.com/resources/files.html

Chromix test image page - lots of good test images to download

Reichmann's simple guide to Epson printer settings
http://www.luminous-landscape.com/tutorials/understanding-series/und-print-mgmt.shtml

Good screenshots of printer/software set up
http://www.inkjetmall.com/store/techsupport/photoshop6-tutorial.html

Good detailed info on how profiles, out of gamut colors, and related info works.  Good interactive diagrams where you move your mouse over colors to see which are out of gamut...
http://www.boscarol.com/pages/cms_eng/

Basic pdf on when to use sRGB, RGB, or .raw
http://www.digitaldog.net/files/R1-2-rodney.pdf



Kodak information
What is a color profile?
http://www.kodak.com/global/en/professional/member/photoPrinters/ICCProfiles.jhtml?id=0.1.22.16.5.26.3&lc=en

Kodak profile pdf's
http://www.kodak.com/global/en/service/professional/products/ekn02891.jhtml?id=0.1.14.24&lc=en

A color printer profile is a small software file that describes how ink interacts with a specific type of paper, within a specific printing system. In this case, your printer. Using the right ICC Color Profile for your printer is one of the easiest steps you can take toward better prints. Your print driver will use the profile to adjust the output of ink to match the colors, contrast, and brightness in the picture file. The result is better, more consistent, even amazing prints.

Your printer came with profiles that are specific to the manufacturer’s paper, but all papers are made slightly (or dramatically) different. By using the profiles we made specifically for your printer (along with the correct Printer Driver settings), you’ll get the best possible prints on KODAK PROFESSIONAL Inkjet Photo Paper. If you’re looking for color predictability and consistency, download the profile for your printer and operating system, and get the results you expect – every time.


Canon

Canon printers

Canon color information for Canon printers - pdf


Epson

Epson printers

Epson color workflow for Epson printers


Ilford

Ilford information



Photoshop Elements Color Help
From Elements 4:  To set up color management
In the Editor, choose Edit > Color Settings.
Select one of the following color management options:
No Color Management Leaves your image untagged. This option uses your monitor profile as the working space. It removes any embedded profiles when opening images, and does not tag when saving.
Always Optimize Colors For Computer Screens Uses sRGB as the working space, preserves embedded profiles, and assigns sRGB when opening untagged files.
Always Optimize For Printing Uses AdobeRGB as the working space, preserves embedded profiles, and assigns Adobe RGB when opening untagged files.
Allow Me To Choose Lets you choose sRGB (the default) or AdobeRGB when opening untagged files.
Click OK.
When you save a file, select ICC Profile in the Save As dialog box.



From Elements 3 Help files
About color management

Color management helps you to get consistent color between scanners, computer monitors, and printers. Each of these devices reproduces a different range of colors, called a color gamut. As you move an image from your scanner to your monitor, and finally to a printer, the image colors shift because every device has a different color gamut.

If you use color management, the image colors are translated so that each device can reproduce them in the same way. The colors you see on your monitor will be close to the colors in your printed image. All colors may not match exactly because the printer may not reproduce the same range of colors as the monitor.

For color management to work, you must profile your devices or use an ICC profile created by the device’s manufacturer.

Profiling is not critical for capture devices such as digital cameras or scanners. You may want to profile a scanner, however, if you want to accurately reproduce the colors in scanned transparencies. This can save you color correction work in Photoshop Elements.

Profiling and calibrating your monitor is important. If you don’t own a colorimeter and the software to do this, you can use Adobe Gamma software on Windows (if you have a CRT monitor) and the Apple Display Calibrator Assistant on Mac OS. Adobe Gamma is included with your Photoshop Elements software. If you are using a laptop or other LCD monitor, you can use the profile provided by the manufacturer.

Profiling your inkjet printer will generally give you better results, though you can make excellent prints without a printer profile by using the controls in your printer driver. Many printer manufacturers provide ICC printer profiles on their web sites. You need a separate profile for each printer, ink, and type of paper. You can also have profiles made for your favorite combination of ink and paper.

When you work on a photo and save it, you can have Photoshop Elements embed (tag) an ICC profile that reflects the colors you saw on your computer monitor. If you send the photo to your inkjet printer, the color management system reads the embedded profile and translates the color data using the printer’s profile. Your printer can then use the translated color data.

If you want to use color management, you need to do the following tasks:

Make sure that color management is set up to embed a color profile.

Calibrate and profile your computer monitor. If you use an LCD monitor, use the profile that came with your monitor. See your LCD monitor documentation for instructions.

When you print an image, make sure that in the Print dialog box Photoshop Elements reads the embedded color profile so that it can translate the image data using the correct printer profile. Or, if you don’t have a printer profile, use the color controls in the printer driver to get the color you want. See printing individual photos in help for more information

From Elements 3 Help Files
About printing with consistent color


Your monitor displays an image using light, and a desktop printer reproduces an image using inks, dyes, or pigments. For this reason, it is impossible for a desktop printer to reproduce all the colors that can be displayed on a monitor. However, by using certain procedures (such as color management), you can achieve predictable results when printing your images on a desktop printer. Using color management, photos from your printer more closely match the color and tone of the images you see on your monitor.

The first step in matching color is to characterize and profile your computer’s monitor. After your monitor is profiled, you can use color management in one of two ways:

Printer driver color management. Instead of the controls in Photoshop Elements, use the controls in your printer driver dialog box to adjust color settings until you get a printed image color that you like.

Color profile conversion. Photoshop Elements translates color data using an ICC profile embedded in your image to a custom ICC profile for your printer/paper combination. Your printer may have come with a set of profiles for different papers. When using the Photoshop Elements controls, turn off your printer driver’s color management controls, or you’ll color manage your image twice and get unpredictable color. For more accurate color, you can have a color profile made for your printer and favorite paper.

In either case, perfect color prints are not automatic. You might need to do some fine-tuning to get the color you want.

From Elements 3 Help files
Color management print options

To set color management options in the Print Preview dialog box, make sure that Show More Options is selected.

Source Space. (also known as Image Space) Displays the image’s current ICC profile. This will usually be Adobe RGB if you have set up color management for printing.

Print Space. Sets a custom printer profile to convert image colors to the printer’s color space, or turns off color conversion. If you have an ICC profile for your printer and paper combination, choose it from the menu. Make sure that you turn off the printer driver’s color management.

Same as Source. Uses the image’s profile, so no translation is done. PostScript Color Management passes the color data to the printer driver without converting it. You then set the printer driver controls to convert the color.

Intent. (Also know as rendering intent) Specifies how colors are translated from the image’s source color space when certain colors are not available in the print space. This option is only available in the Print Preview dialog box.

Perceptual. Use for photographic images to preserve the visual relationship between colors. All color values may be shifted to fit the printer profile’s color space. Perceptual is a good choice when many colors are outside the range of colors in the color space (out of gamut).

Relative Colorimetric. Use for photographic images when you want to preserve the colors available in both the source and destination spaces. Out of gamut colors are shifted (mapped) to close matching colors in the printer profile’s color space. The shifting of colors is done in such a way that the overall appearance of the image is preserved.

Saturation. Use for business graphics if the exact relationship between colors is not as important as having bright saturated colors. Saturation creates vivid color at the expense of accurate color.

Absolute Colorimetric. Use for proofing to simulate another printer and paper. For example, use Absolute Colorimetric to reproduce the appearance of a sheet of newsprint onto a sheet of bright white paper. The bright white paper would be printed over with a dingy gray to simulate the actual newsprint appearance.

From Elements 3 Help files
To print using color management


Do the following:

Set up your devices for color management. Calibrate your monitor and create a profile for it. Use Adobe Gamma or, for more precise calibration, use third-party software and hardware. If profiles came with your printer, make sure they’re installed on your computer. For important color work, it’s highly recommended that you create custom profiles for each type of paper that you use with the printer.

Note: For Windows XP, ICC profiles are stored in WINDOWS > system 32 > spool > drivers > color. For Windows 2000, ICC profiles are stored in WINNT > system 32 > spool > drivers > color.

Set up the Photoshop Elements color management system. Choose Edit > Color Settings to specify the color management settings. Select the Full Color Management option in the Color Settings dialog box. This setting is optimized for print and uses Adobe RGB as the working color space.

Edit your image in Photoshop Elements. For consistent results, work in RGB and don’t convert your photo to a different mode.

Set the Print Space options. Use the Print command to open Print Preview or Print Selected Photos (Print Photos) dialog box. In the Print Preview dialog box, select Show More Options. In the Print Selected Photos (Print Photos) dialog box, click the More Options button. The following color management options are available:

The Source Space (Image Space) shows the color space embedded in your photo file (if a color space is embedded).

Note: If you are printing a multi-image layout, and images have different source spaces, all the images selected for printing will be converted to the working color space before being sent to the printer. One exception is an image with P.I.M. data, which is always converted to sRGB.

Use the Print Space menu to choose the profile of your printer or your custom profile of a specific printer/paper combination. Photoshop Elements will handle the color management during printing. In the Print Preview dialog box only, choose Printer Color Management if your printer driver is handling the color management during printing.

(Print Preview dialog box only) Use the Intent menu to choose a rendering intent. Relative Colorimetric or Perceptual are commonly used for photographic images because they preserve the overall appearance of a document’s colors when printed.

Set printer options. Click the Print button in the Print Preview dialog box to set options in the Print dialog box (for setting printer options). The options vary according to the printer drivers installed on your computer. If Photoshop Elements is handling the color adjustment or color management options during printing, turn off all printer driver color adjustment options. If not, specify the color management settings for your printer driver. It’s important not to use both Photoshop Elements and the printer driver setting simultaneously. This results in unpredictable color.

Color management print options

To set color management options in the Print Preview dialog box, make sure that Show More Options is selected.

Source Space. (also known as Image Space) Displays the image’s current ICC profile. This will usually be Adobe RGB if you have set up color management for printing.

Print Space. Sets a custom printer profile to convert image colors to the printer’s color space, or turns off color conversion. If you have an ICC profile for your printer and paper combination, choose it from the menu. Make sure that you turn off the printer driver’s color management.

Same as Source. Uses the image’s profile, so no translation is done. PostScript Color Management passes the color data to the printer driver without converting it. You then set the printer driver controls to convert the color.

Intent. (Also know as rendering intent) Specifies how colors are translated from the image’s source color space when certain colors are not available in the print space. This option is only available in the Print Preview dialog box.

Perceptual. Use for photographic images to preserve the visual relationship between colors. All color values may be shifted to fit the printer profile’s color space. Perceptual is a good choice when many colors are outside the range of colors in the color space (out of gamut).

Relative Colorimetric. Use for photographic images when you want to preserve the colors available in both the source and destination spaces. Out of gamut colors are shifted (mapped) to close matching colors in the printer profile’s color space. The shifting of colors is done in such a way that the overall appearance of the image is preserved.

Saturation. Use for business graphics if the exact relationship between colors is not as important as having bright saturated colors. Saturation creates vivid color at the expense of accurate color.

Absolute Colorimetric. Use for proofing to simulate another printer and paper. For example, use Absolute Colorimetric to reproduce the appearance of a sheet of newsprint onto a sheet of bright white paper. The bright white paper would be printed over with a dingy gray to simulate the actual newsprint appearance.


Colorimeters

PC Photo reviews of color correction devices

1-19-2006 Michael Reichmann reviews the PrintFix Pro

Pantone

Colorvision

Monaco Xrite - Order free materials from Xrite (Monaco)


Good info from
http://www.drycreekphoto.com/Learn/monitor_calibration_tools.htm

The Spyder2 exhibits two quirks. First, it is slow. You can make a sandwich and read most of a daily paper in the time it takes to measure a monitor. Second, the exceptional shadow performance does not carry over into the highlights. The Spyder2 does not measure any light colors - only up to the primary (e.g. [255, 0, 0] for red) values. The profiles appear to reflect this, with more abrupt highlight transitions than those made by GretagMacbeth or Monaco equipment. If shadow detail and accuracy are paramount, the Spyder2 is the one to buy. Wedding photographers faced with the combination of bright lights and slightly off-white gowns should look elsewhere. The Spyder2 is not as sensitive to ambient light levels as the original, but it is still advisable to perform the measurements in a darkened room. Recommended. Would be highly recommended if the highlight performance matched that of the midtones and shadows.

GretagMacbeth Eye-One Display (original version): The Eye-One Match 3.0 software is compatible with both the Eye-One One and the Eye-One Two. Aside from silly naming conventions, the original Eye-One Display held its own. Overall, the original Eye-One Display rates a notch below the Spyder2. It generally surpassed the Spyder2 in dealing with extreme highlights as colors faded to white.  Owners of the original Eye-One Display hardware should download the free upgrade to Match 3.0.

GretagMacbeth Spectrolino: At something over $6000 list, the GretagMacbeth Spectrolino + ProfileMaker Pro software is not realistic to use for monitor profiling alone. The ProfileMaker software affords more options and allows precise fine-tuning of the calibration parameters. This venerable instrument was used as a baseline for comparison. It is an expensive, heavy, slow, and superbly accurate spectrophotometer. Overall, the tide looks to be shifting towards colorimeters. The overall performance falls in the range of the Spyder2. A Spectrolino is still a fine instrument, but unless you need oddball printer profiling capability as well, there are better ways to spend your money.

ColorVision Spyder (original version): The original ColorVision Spyder simply was not competitive with the above products. ColorVision deserves much credit for bringing the first reasonably priced monitor calibration and profiling tool to market. The Spyder certainly remains better than calibrating by eye. Shadow resolution, grayscale neutrality, color accuracy — the original Spyder falls short in all these areas. There are better options.

LaCie Blue-Eye One: I can think of no reason to purchase the LaCie Blue-Eye system. It uses the same hardware as the original Eye-One Display, but the software does little to take advantage of it. The Blue-Eye costs more than the DDC-enabled Eye-One 2 and does less. Not recommended.

Eizo ColorNavigator: The Eizo ColorNavigator software comes for free with the monitor. You need to supply your own Eye-One. The grayscale was OK, and the gamma curve nearly perfect. Color response was not. Use the Eye-One with the new version of GretagMacbeth software.

Which product should I purchase?
On high quality monitors, ColorEyes Display gives the best balance of accuracy, smooth tonality, shadow resolution, and calibration flexibility. Using the software effectively takes careful reading of the user's manual. This is made more difficult because the installation program does not copy the help file to your computer. There is also no on-line help except for a few prompts which may or may not have anything to do with what is shown on-screen. ColorEyes offers automatic DDC control over the hardware settings for selected monitors. Once you have mastered its quirks, the calibration and profiling of good quality monitors is simply superb. Getting the most out of ColorEyes Display requires either using the bundled version with the Monaco XR/X-Rite DTP-94 puck or the GretagMacbeth Eye-One 2. Although the software supports older measurement hardware (e.g. Sequel Squid, Eye-One Display One), the profile quality can not compare.

You can not go wrong with the Monaco Optix XR Pro. It matches well with most monitors, and offers useful data analysis and trending capabilities. If you do not need display matching, performance trending, and other workgroup features, the added cost of the Pro package is significant. Unfortunately, the base version with its reduced feature set is not competitive.

The GretagMacbeth Eye-One Display 2 is a good performer. Overall color performance is excellent. The calibration options are not as extensive as those of the Optix XR or Spyder2. If your monitor is DDC-enabled, the Eye-One Match 3 software performs the necessary monitor adjustments automatically (Mac only for now - Windows capability is "coming soon"). The fast speed, particularly on CRT monitors, makes for quick and painless calibration and profiling.

The ColorVision Spyder2 is a mixed performer. The limitation is in how highlights are handled. If your photography requires excellent shadow response or superb B&W performance, the Spyder2 is ideal. The included software offers the most flexibility of any of the recommended systems. Wedding photographers, or others needing to see delicate highlight details will do better with one of the above systems.



Rendering Intents

Cambridge rendering intent info - very good

Norman Koren's take on rendering intents
http://www.normankoren.com/color_management.html#Rendering_intent


Recommendations - Borrowed information - not authored by Jeff Adams 
So which is the best rendering intent for digital photography? In general, perceptual and relative colorimetric are best suited for photography because they aim to preserve the same visual appearance as the original.

The decision about when to use each of these depends on image content and the intended purpose. Images with intense colors (such as bright sunsets or well-lit floral arrangements) will preserve more of their color gradation in extreme colors using perceptual intent. On the other hand, this may come at the expense of compressing or dulling more moderate colors. Images with more subtle tones (such as some portraits) often stand to benefit more from the increased accuracy of relative colorimetric (assuming no colors are placed within the gamut mismatch region). Perceptual intent is overall the safest bet for general and batch use, unless you know specifics about each image.

The following table summarizes the characteristics of pigment and dye inks:
Characteristic  Pigment Ink     Dye Ink
Light Fastness  Superior        Inferior       
Colour Gamut    Narrow Colour Gamut     Wide Colour Gamut      
Water fastness  Superior        Inferior       
Colour Impression       Relatively Dull Relatively Bright/Vivid
Overall fastness        Relatively superior     Relatively Inferior    
Stability of Head       Relatively Inferior     Relatively superior